nutella sandwich ideas
intro
Three easy, versatile Nutella sandwiches, from no-cook classic to crispy grilled, perfect for quick snacks, summer picnic packing, or last-minute sweet treats.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Bread and Toppings
Lay all 6 bread slices (2 soft white, 2 sourdough, 2 brioche) on the light oak cutting board. Slice the banana into uniform 1/4-inch thick rounds, hull and slice strawberries into 1/8-inch thick pieces, and pluck 4 small basil leaves from the sprig. Place each prepped topping into its own clear glass ramekin on the back left counter, with softened butter in the third ramekin for easy access.
Make Classic Nutella Sandwich
Take the two slices of soft white sandwich bread. Use the matte black butter knife to spread 2 tablespoons of Nutella evenly across one side of each slice, leaving a 1/4-inch border at the edges to prevent oozing when pressed. Press the two slices together firmly, Nutella sides facing inward. Set the assembled sandwich temporarily on the top corner of the cutting board.
Build Strawberry Basil Sandwich
Take the two slices of soft brioche bread. Spread 2.5 tablespoons of Nutella evenly across one side of each slice, leaving a small border. Arrange thin strawberry slices in a single overlapping layer across one Nutella-covered slice, then tuck 3 small basil leaves between the strawberry pieces. Press the second brioche slice on top, Nutella side down, and set next to the classic sandwich on the cutting board.
Prep Grilled Banana Filling
Take the two slices of sourdough bread. Spread 2.5 tablespoons of Nutella evenly across one side of each slice. Arrange banana slices in a single tight layer across one Nutella-covered slice, pressing them lightly into the spread to help them stick. Top with the second sourdough slice, Nutella side down, to form the sandwich. Set aside while you prepare the pan.
Grill Sourdough Banana Sandwich
Use your fingers to spread half the softened butter (1.5 tsp) evenly across the top outer surface of the sourdough sandwich. Place the sandwich butter-side down in the silver skillet set over medium-low heat. Spread the remaining butter across the now-exposed top slice of bread. Cook for 1.5 minutes, until the bottom slice is deep golden and crispy, then use the silicone-tipped spatula to flip the sandwich. Cook the second side for another 1.5 minutes, until golden and the Nutella is soft and melted inside. Remove from heat and set on the cutting board to cool for 1 minute.
Cut Sandwiches for Serving
Transfer all three assembled sandwiches (classic white, strawberry brioche, grilled banana sourdough) to the center of the cutting board. Use the matte black butter knife to cut each sandwich diagonally into two equal triangular halves. Wipe any excess Nutella smudges off the knife between cuts to keep edges neat. Lightly dust the grilled banana sandwich halves with the 1 teaspoon of powdered sugar for a finished look.
Arrange Sandwiches on Platter
Arrange the 6 sandwich halves in a loose overlapping fan on the matte cream white ceramic serving platter. Tuck the remaining small basil leaf next to the strawberry brioche halves as a fresh garnish. Let the grilled sandwich cool for 1 more minute so the Nutella does not run excessively when served.
Tips
2.Grill the banana Nutella sandwich only on medium-low heat. High heat will burn the sourdough crust before the Nutella melts and banana softens inside, leading to a bitter, unevenly cooked sandwich.
3.For picnic transport, wrap each sandwich half tightly in parchment paper and chill for 10 minutes before packing. This helps the Nutella set slightly, preventing leaks and keeping sandwich layers intact while on the go.

OMG these are such a game changer for after school snacks! My 7 and 9 year old devoured the banana + Nutella + sprinkle one in 2 minutes flat. 3 minutes total prep is so perfect for our chaotic weekday evenings, no fancy ingredients needed.
Tried the marshmallow fluff + Nutella combo for my dorm movie night last night and everyone was begging for the recipe! SO good, I didn't even have to cook anything, just assembled it in between study sessions. 10/10
Threw the peanut butter + Nutella + pretzel crunch version together for our day hike last weekend and it held up perfectly in my pack. Salty sweet combo hits so hard when you're 3 miles in, no messy drips if you press the bread edges down.
Made these for a casual girls' brunch and cut them into little tea sandwich triangles, they were gone in 10 minutes! The flaky sea salt sprinkle on the classic Nutella one is chef's kiss, I never thought to add that before. Used sourdough instead of plain white and it tasted even better, highly recommend that swap.
I was skeptical these would hold up for meal prep but I wrapped the peanut butter Nutella ones individually in parchment and they stayed perfect in the fridge for 3 days for quick work snacks. No soggy bread at all! Total weekday lifesaver.
Wait, the grilled Nutella and strawberry one? LIFE CHANGING. I didn't even know you could make a warm Nutella sandwich that fast on a pan, no fancy panini press needed. My only question is can I use frozen strawberries if I don't have fresh?
Brought the Nutella + bacon + banana sandwich bites to my office potluck yesterday and people were literally coming back for thirds. Who knew crispy bacon and Nutella were such a perfect pair?
These look so good! Has anyone tried making these with gluten free bread? I have a sensitivity and don't want the bread to fall apart when I assemble them.
Made the classic Nutella sandwich with a little extra Nutella (obviously) for my teen daughter after her soccer practice and she said it's better than the ones she gets at the concession stand. Win for dad!
Tried the marshmallow Nutella one as a 2am snack after my shift at the hospital and it was the best decision I made all week. Only thing is I got Nutella all over my scrubs, 100% worth it though.
Wait, has anyone swapped the Nutella for vegan hazelnut spread for these? I'm vegan and miss quick sweet snacks like this so bad!
My super picky 3 year old refused every after school snack I offered until I made the sprinkle Nutella sandwich from this recipe. He ate the whole thing without throwing any on the floor! I could cry, thank you.
My husband is obsessed with Nutella so I made all three of these for our 1 year anniversary at home date night, and he said they're better than the fancy dessert we got at our wedding. Total win!
Planning a cross country road trip next month and I'm prepping a ton of easy no-mess snacks for the drive. Do these hold up if I make them the night before and keep them in a cooler?
Wait, for the grilled version, do I need to butter the outside of the bread like a regular grilled cheese? I'm a terrible cook and don't want to burn it lol
Brought these to my neighborhood block party last weekend, cut into bite sized quarters with little toothpicks, and I swear every single parent asked me for the recipe. The pretzel crunch one is the undisputed crowd favorite!
I added a little drizzle of caramel sauce to the banana Nutella one and OH MY GOD it's like eating a gourmet dessert for a snack. Why didn't I think of this combo sooner?
I'm a 2nd grade teacher and I made these for our class end of week celebration, and every single kid finished their sandwich, even the ones who usually say they don't like sweet snacks. The sprinkle version is basically kid catnip.