homemade cheese
intro
Creamy, mild fresh homemade cheese made with 5 simple ingredients, perfect for spreading on crusty bread, pairing with spring fruit, or adding to salads. No special cheesemaking equipment required for this beginner-friendly project.
Ingredients
Steps
Prep Draining Station
Line the 20cm fine-mesh stainless steel sieve with 2 layers of the natural off-white cotton cheesecloth, leaving 5cm of cheesecloth overhang around all sieve edges. Set the lined sieve inside the 4L clear glass heatproof mixing bowl, so the sieve sits 5cm above the bowl bottom to catch drained whey. Keep this assembled setup in its fixed center-right position on the counter.
Heat Milk Slowly
Pour 2L of whole (non-ultra-pasteurized) cow's milk into the 5L stainless steel stockpot. Set over medium-low heat, stirring slowly and regularly with the long-handled slotted stainless steel spoon to prevent milk from scalding on the pot bottom. Heat the milk until it reaches a steady 93°C (200°F), verified with the digital instant-read thermometer held in the center of the milk (do not touch the pot bottom with the probe, as this will give an inaccurate high reading). Do not allow the milk to reach a rolling boil, as high heat creates tough, rubbery curds.
Add Acid to Curdle
Turn off the heat under the pot. Pour the 60ml of white distilled vinegar from the small glass measuring cup into the hot milk, stirring slowly and gently with the slotted spoon for 10 seconds to distribute the acid evenly. You will immediately see soft white curds begin to separate from the pale, translucent yellow-green whey. Let the mixture rest, undisturbed, for 10 minutes to allow curds to fully form and firm up slightly.
Strain Curds from Whey
Gently ladle the curds and whey into the cheesecloth-lined sieve using the slotted spoon, pouring slowly to avoid splashing. Let the initial watery whey drain through the cloth into the glass bowl below for 1 minute, then lightly shake the sieve to help excess whey drain away from the curds.
Season Curds Lightly
Open the top of the cheesecloth bundle to expose the warm, drained curds. Sprinkle 1 teaspoon of fine sea salt over the curds, then use the tip of the slotted spoon to toss the curds gently to distribute the salt evenly. Taste a small crumb of curd, and add a pinch more salt if desired for a savorier cheese.
Press Cheese to Set
Gather the cheesecloth edges tightly again around the salted curds, twisting the top gently to squeeze out excess whey: squeeze gently for a soft, spreadable cheese, squeeze more firmly for a firmer, sliceable cheese. Set the off-white matte ceramic serving plate on top of the twisted cheese bundle, then place the matte cream ceramic salt cellar on top of the plate as a gentle weight. Let the cheese press and drain for 45 minutes to 1 hour at room temperature, until it holds a firm, solid round shape.
Unmold Finished Cheese
After 1 hour of pressing, remove the salt cellar weight and serving plate (return the salt cellar to its fixed position on the counter), untwist the cheesecloth top. Gently peel the cheesecloth away from the firm, smooth round of fresh cheese. Invert the cheese onto the off-white matte ceramic serving plate, so the smooth, unmarked side faces up, ready for garnishing and serving.
Tips
2.Do not over-stir after adding vinegar: stirring too aggressively will break tender curds into tiny pieces that slip through the cheesecloth, reducing your final cheese yield and creating a mushy, uneven texture.
3.Save the drained whey left in the glass bowl: this protein-rich, slightly tangy liquid can be used in place of water for bread baking, blended into smoothies, or added to soup stocks to reduce food waste and add subtle flavor.

OMG this was SO good! I’ve been intimidated to make homemade cheese forever but this was genuinely so easy, even with my three kids running around the kitchen begging for snacks the whole time. I served it sliced with fresh apple slices and crackers for our after-school snack spread yesterday, and all three boys devoured it before I could even get a photo for my Instagram. Game changer for quick, no-fuss snacks! The 1 hour press time was perfect because I could get homework done while it set, no constant babysitting required.
Tried this last weekend for a small cookout with my roommates, we used it on top of grilled burgers and everyone lost their minds. Who knew homemade cheese was this straightforward? The only thing I messed up was I cut my curds a little too big at first, so they didn’t drain quite as evenly, but even then it turned out creamy and delicious. Will 100% make again for our next potluck.
Made this with fresh raw milk from the small family farm down the road from my house and it tasted like pure summer. So creamy, mild, perfect for slicing up to add to my lunch salads all week for meal prep. 10/10, no notes, this is going into my regular rotation.
Wait, hold on, I thought making cheese at home required all kinds of fancy equipment? I only have a regular colander and some cheesecloth, no fancy cheese press — will this still work? I really want to make this for my daughter’s birthday brunch next weekend but I don’t have time to order special gear.
This was such a fun weekend project! I pressed mine for an extra 20 minutes because I like a firmer cheese that crumbles a little easier for salads, and it turned out perfectly. I even saved the whey to use in my sourdough bread baking, zero waste!
As a broke college student who’s sick of pre-shredded cheese that tastes like plastic, this was a revelation. All the ingredients are cheap, it doesn’t take that much active work, and I feel like a whole professional chef making my own cheese. My dorm neighbors all knocked on my door when they smelled it cooking and begged for bites lmao.
I’ve been making farmhouse cheese for 40 years and I have to say, this recipe is the simplest, most consistent version I’ve ever tried. I taught my 10-year-old granddaughter how to make it last weekend and she did almost all the steps by herself! We added a little dill from my garden to half the batch and it was divine with our Sunday dinner ham.
Question for folks who’ve made this — how long does this keep in the fridge? I want to make a big batch on Sunday to use for sandwiches, cheese boards, and snack time for the whole week, but I don’t want it to go bad before we get through it.
Wait a second, can I crumble this over tacos? I know it’s farmhouse cheese but I’m obsessed with queso fresco and I’m wondering if this is a dupe if I press it a little less? Would that work to get that crumbly, fresh texture I love on street tacos?
Made this last night and added a pinch of smoked paprika and a little flaky sea salt on the outside after pressing, and it tasted like the fancy $12/lb cheese they sell at the farmers market. My partner thought I bought it until I told him I made it from scratch in less than an hour and a half. Total win.
Quick question — does this recipe call for any rennet? My kid has a really bad sensitivity to animal-derived rennet so I need to make sure before I gather ingredients, I’d love to make a cheese that’s safe for him to eat without buying a specialty brand.
First time making cheese ever, and I’ll be honest I was sure I was going to mess it up. I heated the milk a tiny bit too hot at first, but I pulled it off the heat, let it cool a couple degrees, and kept going, and it still turned out amazing! Sliced it up for our family dinner charcuterie board and everyone raved. So approachable for total newbies.
This is perfect for my high protein meal prep! It’s so much lower in weird additives than store-bought cheese, and I can control exactly how much salt goes in which is great for my fitness goals. I’ve been adding slices to my egg breakfast sandwiches every morning this week and it’s chef’s kiss.
Served this at my girls’ brunch last weekend with homemade jam, crusty sourdough, and fresh berries, and every single person asked me for the recipe. I felt like such a fancy hostess and I barely had to do any work! The inactive press time meant I could set it and finish getting the rest of the brunch spread ready without hovering over the stove.
I tried making this yesterday with skim milk because that’s all I had on hand, and it turned out really rubbery and didn’t have that creamy texture everyone is talking about. Did I do something wrong? I followed all the steps exactly otherwise.