peanut butter nutella sandwich
intro
Rich, creamy peanut butter and silky chocolate-hazelnut Nutella sandwiched between crisp, lightly toasted bread, balanced with a pinch of flaky salt for a fast, satisfying treat.
Ingredients
Steps
Arrange bread slices
Remove 4 even slices of soft white sandwich bread from the plain brown paper bread bag, discarding any dry end pieces if preferred. Lay the slices in a single flat layer on the pale maple cutting board, checking that no slices have tears or holes that would cause spread to leak out. Brush any loose crumbs off the bread surface with a clean finger.
Portion the spreads
Using the taupe silicone spatula, scoop 4 tablespoons of creamy peanut butter from the unlabeled jar into one clear glass ramekin, and 3 tablespoons of Nutella into the second ramekin. Wipe excess spread off the spatula edge on the ramekin rim to avoid drips. Let the Nutella sit for 1 minute at room temperature if it is too stiff to spread easily straight from the jar.
Toast bread lightly
Place the 8-inch non-stick skillet over medium-low heat (325°F / 160°C). Add the 1 teaspoon of unsalted butter, swirling to coat the pan surface once melted. Lay all 4 bread slices in the skillet in a single layer, toasting for 45-60 seconds per side until the surface is pale golden and crisp to the touch, not dark brown. Remove toasted bread from the skillet and place it back on the maple cutting board to cool for 30 seconds so spreads do not run excessively, wiping excess butter from the pan with the corner of the fixed linen towel.
Spread peanut butter layer
Pick up the matte black butter knife. Use it to scoop 2 tablespoons of peanut butter from the ramekin, spreading it in a thin, even 1/8-inch thick layer all the way to the edges of two of the toasted bread slices. Apply gentle, even pressure to avoid tearing the soft toasted bread surface, ensuring no bare spots are left on the bread.
Spread Nutella layer
Wipe excess peanut butter off the butter knife with a quick wipe on the peanut butter ramekin edge, then use it to scoop 1.5 tablespoons of Nutella per slice, spreading it in an even 1/8-inch thick layer across the remaining two toasted bread slices, again spreading all the way to the edges. Do not press too hard, as Nutella is softer than peanut butter and will tear the bread if excess pressure is applied.
Press sandwich halves
Carefully lift one peanut butter-topped slice and flip it peanut butter-side down onto one Nutella-topped slice, aligning the edges perfectly. Repeat with the remaining two slices to make a second full sandwich. Press down gently on the top of each sandwich with the palm of your hand to help the spreads adhere and seal the edges, pressing just hard enough to make the spreads ooze very slightly at the seam, not so hard that they squeeze out excessively.
Season with flaky salt
Sprinkle the tiny pinch of flaky sea salt evenly across the top surface of both sandwiches, pressing lightly so the salt flakes stick to the toasted bread. The salt cuts through the richness of the sweet and nutty spreads, balancing the flavor without making the sandwich taste salty.
Cut and plate sandwiches
Use the butter knife to cut each sandwich diagonally from corner to corner, creating four triangular halves. Wipe the knife blade clean between cuts to avoid smearing spreads across the bread crust. Arrange the four triangles on the matte cream stoneware serving plate, fanning them slightly so the cut, swirled spread layers face outward toward the viewer.
Tips
2.Toast bread only to pale golden, not dark brown: overly dark, crispy toast is brittle and cracks when bitten into, causing spreads to squeeze out the sides; pale golden toast has a crisp outer surface and soft, tender center that holds spreads well.
3.Let toasted bread cool 30 seconds before adding spreads: hot bread will melt Nutella into a thin, runny liquid that soaks into the bread and creates a soggy texture, instead of keeping a distinct, creamy spread layer.

OMG this is the easiest after-school snack I’ve ever made! My 7 and 9 year old devoured these in 2 minutes flat, and I didn’t even have to turn on the oven. Game changer for busy weekday afternoons when we’re running between soccer practice and homework. 10/10, will be making these weekly!
Wait why did I never think to put these two together before? 2 minutes cook time is perfect for when I’m pulling an all-nighter studying for midterms and don’t want to order expensive takeout. SO good, I added a few banana slices in mine for extra texture.
I brought a platter of cut-up quarters of these sandwiches to our neighborhood block party potluck last weekend and they were gone in 10 minutes! People kept asking me for the recipe like it was some fancy baked good, nope, just two spreads on bread lmao. Only note: I used crusty sourdough instead of white bread and it held up really well for a crowd.
Wait y’all, I was skeptical at first because I’m a total peanut butter purist, but the Nutella adds the perfect little chocolatey kick without being too sweet. I make this for my weekend hiking trips because it’s portable and gives me that quick energy boost on the trails.
I made this for my little cousin’s sleepover last night and all the girls were raving. We set up a little sandwich bar with extra toppings like sprinkles, mini marshmallows, and sliced strawberries so they could customize their own. Way easier than baking cookies for a crowd of hyper 10 year olds tbh.
Wait has anyone tried making these ahead for weekly meal prep? I’m wondering if the Nutella and peanut butter make the bread soggy if I store them in the fridge for 3-4 days?
I ate way too many of these after my workout yesterday lmao. I thought I’d make one as a quick post-gym snack and ended up making three because they’re that addictive. 10/10 no notes, except maybe don’t make them when you’re home alone because you will eat the whole batch.
Uh, is this supposed to be as good as it is? I can barely make toast without burning it and I pulled this off no problem. My roommate thought I ordered takeout dessert when he walked in and smelled the Nutella lmao. Super easy, zero skill required, 10/10 for beginner cooks like me.
My granddaughter taught me how to make this last weekend when she came to visit. I used my homemade peanut butter that I can every fall and it was just divine. Reminds me of the peanut butter and marshmallow sandwiches I used to make for her dad when he was little, just a little fancier with the chocolate spread.
I served these cut into little triangles at my last girls’ brunch alongside mimosas and fruit salad and everyone was obsessed. Who knew a simple sandwich could be such a crowd pleaser? I even added a thin layer of raspberry jam to half of them for a little fruity twist, chef’s kiss.