southern pimento cheese
intro
Creamy, tangy, sharp Southern pimento cheese: the iconic no-cook spread, perfect for crackers, sandwiches, and veggie dippers, packed with bold, nostalgic classic flavor.
Ingredients
Steps
Grate Sharp Cheddar
Set the stainless steel box grater firmly on the surface of the maple cutting board. Hold the block of sharp yellow cheddar against the large, coarse holes of the grater, applying firm, even downward pressure to grate all cheese into light, fluffy, coarse shreds. Avoid using pre-shredded store-bought cheese, as it is coated in anti-caking starch that creates a grainy final texture. When fully grated, transfer all cheddar shreds to the clear glass mixing bowl.
Pat Pimentos Dry
Pour the jarred diced pimentos onto a double layer of white paper towel laid on the empty corner of the maple cutting board. Pat the top surface of the pimentos firmly with a second paper towel to absorb all excess brine, until pimentos feel dry to the touch with no visible liquid pooling. Excess brine will thin the spread and create a watery consistency, so do not rush this step. Add the fully dried pimentos to the glass mixing bowl on top of the grated cheddar.
Add Creamy Bases
Add the fully softened room-temperature cream cheese and full-fat mayonnaise to the glass mixing bowl on top of the grated cheddar and dried pimentos. Test cream cheese softness by pressing a finger into the block: it should indent easily with no firm core. If cream cheese is still cold and firm, let it rest at room temperature for 10 additional minutes before proceeding, as cold cream cheese will leave hard lumps in the finished spread.
Add Seasoning Spices
Measure and add Worcestershire sauce, garlic powder, onion powder, smoked paprika, optional cayenne pepper, freshly ground black pepper, and kosher salt to the mixing bowl. Hold back on extra salt at this stage: cheddar, mayonnaise, and Worcestershire all contain significant sodium, and you will adjust final seasoning after chilling.
Fold to Combine
Use the matte cream silicone spatula to fold the ingredients together, pressing the cream cheese against the side of the bowl to break up small lumps, until the mixture is evenly combined with bright red pimento flecks distributed throughout the golden cheddar base. Do not overmix to a perfectly smooth paste: traditional Southern pimento cheese has a pleasant, slightly chunky texture from hand-grated cheddar. Stop mixing as soon as no streaks of plain mayonnaise or unblended cream cheese remain.
Chill to Meld Flavors
Cover the glass mixing bowl tightly with clear plastic wrap and transfer to the refrigerator to chill for a minimum of 1 hour (and up to 3 days, stored airtight). Chilling allows the spices to infuse into the cheese, mellows the sharp cheddar bite, and firms the spread to the perfect scoopable consistency. Do not serve immediately after mixing, as flavors will taste flat and unbalanced.
Plate and Garnish
Remove the chilled pimento cheese from the refrigerator and uncover. Use the silicone spatula to transfer the spread to the vintage cream white fluted ceramic serving bowl, mounding it softly in the center without pressing it smooth. Dust the top lightly with an extra pinch of smoked paprika, and sprinkle with finely chopped fresh chives. Let the spread rest 5 minutes at room temperature before serving for the creamiest texture.
Tips
2.Pat pimentos completely dry with paper towels before mixing: Excess brine from the pimento jar will thin the spread to a runny consistency, making it too soft to hold its shape for dipping or spreading on crackers and sandwiches.
3.Let the spread chill for at least 1 hour before serving: This resting time allows the garlic, onion, and paprika flavors to infuse into the cheese, mellowing the sharp bite of the cheddar for a balanced, nostalgic flavor instead of a disjointed mix of separate ingredients.

OMG this pimento cheese is SO good! I brought it to my neighborhood potluck last weekend and people were begging me for the recipe before I even left. No cook, 10 minutes to throw together? Total game changer for busy weeknights too.
My kids loved it! I was worried the pimentos would be a hard sell for my picky eaters but they ate it slathered on celery sticks for after school snack all week. Perfect for meal prep too, it stays good in the fridge for days.
Made this for our annual golf trip sandwich spread and it was perfect on white bread with a little crispy bacon. Way better than the store bought tubs we usually grab, will be making this every trip from now on.
Super easy recipe, but I thought it was a little too heavy on the mayo for my taste. Next time I’ll cut the mayo by a tablespoon and add a little extra sharp cheddar to balance it out.
This tastes exactly like my grandma’s pimento cheese she used to make for Sunday family dinners! I haven’t had a version this spot on in years, total nostalgia bomb. Thank you so much for sharing!
Served this as a dip with pretzel crisps and Ritz crackers for the football watch party last Sunday and it was gone by the end of the first quarter. 10/10, will be a regular in my game day rotation.
I’m a born and raised New Yorker so I’ll admit I was skeptical about southern pimento cheese, but wow. This is incredible. I’ve been putting it on everything from burgers to scrambled eggs all week.
This is such a perfect gluten free snack option! I don’t have to worry about weird hidden ingredients, it’s quick to make, and it tastes way fancier than the effort it takes. Love it.
I’m literally just learning to cook and this was so easy I didn’t mess it up! Zero cook time, just mix everything in a bowl, done. I felt so proud bringing something homemade to my friend’s BBQ.
Packed this for our family hike last weekend and it held up perfectly in the cooler, no weird separation or anything. We ate it with tortilla chips and carrot sticks at the summit, such a nice treat.
Took me right back to childhood tea parties with my mom! We used to make little pimento cheese finger sandwiches for every birthday party and this recipe is spot on. The only thing I added was a tiny sprinkle of paprika on top for color.
Made this for brunch last weekend and served it on toasted sourdough with fried green tomatoes on top. Chefs kiss. My guests are still texting me asking how I made it.
I make a snack spread for my office every Friday and this was the star of the show last week. Even our intern who hates cheese went back for three servings. Wild.
This is so much cheaper than buying pre-made pimento cheese from the grocery store! All the ingredients are pantry/fridge staples I usually have on hand anyway, and it tastes 100x better. Total win for my grocery budget.
Full transparency: I’ve hated pimento cheese my whole life, but my husband begged me to make this for his birthday cookout. I tried a bite just to be polite and… I ate half the bowl. What is this magic? I’m a convert now.
Made this in my dorm room with just a bowl and a fork, no fancy equipment needed. My roommates thought I was a gourmet chef, little do they know it took me 8 minutes max. 10/10 easy dorm win.
I added this to my catering menu for small events and it’s been one of my most requested appetizers. I serve it in little individual cups with crackers on the side, it’s such an easy crowd pleaser.
This is a great base recipe! I added a tablespoon of diced pickled jalapenos and a dash of hot sauce to mine and it’s perfect for anyone who likes a little heat. Next time I might even add a sprinkle of bacon bits.
Now that the kids are out of the house I’ve been making smaller batch recipes, and this is perfect. I don’t have a ton of leftovers going to waste, it’s quick to whip up for a quick lunch for me and my husband.
I tested this recipe to add to our shop menu and it’s been flying off the shelves. Customers keep asking if we make it in house (we do!) and saying it’s the best pimento cheese they’ve ever had. Total hit.